Mercedes EQS 580 4Matic vs S 500 4Matic Long: The electric future meets timeless luxury for your ultimate choice.
Choosing between the all-electric Mercedes-Benz EQS 580 4Matic and the gasoline-powered S 500 4Matic Long can feel like selecting a favorite child – both are exceptional. This comparison is for anyone dreaming of a truly luxurious and advanced Mercedes-Benz sedan. We’ll break down what makes each a standout, helping you decide which path to automotive bliss is right for you. Get ready to explore these stunning choices!
The Pinnacle of Mercedes-Benz: Electric Powerhouse Meets Refined Tradition
Choosing a flagship sedan from Mercedes-Benz is always a special occasion. You’re looking at vehicles that define automotive luxury, cutting-edge technology, and unparalleled comfort. The Mercedes-Benz EQS 580 4Matic represents the electric future, a silent revolution on wheels. On the other hand, the S 500 4Matic Long embodies the rich heritage of the S-Class, a legacy of gasoline-powered excellence that has set benchmarks for decades. Both offer the legendary Mercedes-Benz driving experience, but they achieve it through very different philosophies. This choice isn’t just about getting from point A to point B; it’s about your personal values, your driving style, and your vision for luxury transportation.
Understanding the Core Differences: Electric vs. Gasoline at the Top Tier
At their heart, the EQS 580 4Matic and the S 500 4Matic Long represent two distinct eras of automotive engineering. The EQS is built on a dedicated electric vehicle platform, which allows for innovative interior packaging and pure electric performance. The S 500, while incredibly advanced, is an evolution of a long-standing internal combustion engine (ICE) lineage, showcasing the peak of gasoline-powered refinement.
Here’s a quick look at their fundamental differences:
- Powertrain: EQS is all-electric (dual motors), S 500 is a gasoline-powered V8 (with mild-hybrid assistance).
- Platform: EQS uses an EV-dedicated platform; S 500 uses an ICE-based platform.
- “Fueling”: EQS charges at home or public charging stations; S 500 refuels at a gas station.
- Driving Sensation: EQS offers instant torque and silent acceleration; S 500 provides the familiar, robust power delivery of a V8.
Mercedes EQS 580 4Matic: The Electric Revolution
The EQS 580 4Matic is more than just an electric S-Class; it’s a reimagining of what a luxury sedan can be. It’s designed from the ground up to be electric, leading to a unique aesthetic and a spacious interior.
Design and Aerodynamics
One of the most striking aspects of the EQS is its “one-bow” design. This smooth, flowing silhouette isn’t just for looks; it’s incredibly aerodynamic. This low drag coefficient contributes significantly to its impressive range and quiet ride.
- Exterior: Sleek, futuristic, and unmistakably Mercedes-Benz.
- Aerodynamics: Class-leading drag coefficient for maximum efficiency.
- Lighting: Advanced LED lighting systems, including the optional Digital Light.
Performance and Driving Dynamics
The EQS 580 4Matic delivers breathtaking acceleration thanks to its potent dual electric motors. The 4Matic all-wheel-drive system ensures grip and stability in all conditions.
- Horsepower: Approximately 516 hp (can be increased with optional performance package).
- Torque: Immense, instant torque for exhilarating acceleration.
- 0-60 mph: Around 4.1 seconds.
- Handling: A comfortable yet capable ride, with optional rear-axle steering for enhanced maneuverability.
Interior and Technology
Step inside the EQS, and you’re immediately immersed in a cabin that feels like a glimpse into the future. The star of the show is the optional MBUX Hyperscreen, a massive, curved display spanning almost the entire dashboard.
- MBUX Hyperscreen: Three screens seamlessly integrated behind a single glass panel.
- Materials: Sustainable and luxurious materials used throughout.
- Comfort: Advanced climate control, ambient lighting, and optional comfort-focused seating.
- Infotainment: Intuitive and highly customizable system.
Range and Charging
As an electric vehicle, range and charging are key considerations. The EQS 580 4Matic offers a substantial electric range, making it a viable option for many drivers, even for longer journeys.
- Estimated Range: EPA estimates often exceed 300 miles on a full charge (check specific model year for exact figures).
- Charging: Supports Level 2 home charging and DC fast charging at public stations, allowing for quick top-ups.
- Charging Speed: Capable of adding significant range in a short amount of time at a DC fast charger.
Mercedes S 500 4Matic Long: The Epitome of Gasoline Luxury
The S 500 4Matic Long is a testament to Mercedes-Benz’s mastery of the internal combustion engine. It builds upon a legendary lineage, offering a driving experience that is both powerful and incredibly refined. The “Long” designation signifies an extended wheelbase, providing even more rear-seat legroom.
Design and Presence
The S-Class boasts a more traditional, yet undeniably elegant and commanding presence. Its design is timeless, exuding sophistication and prestige.
- Exterior: Classic, stately, and instantly recognizable as a flagship S-Class.
- Proportions: A long hood and refined lines speak to its powerful engine and luxurious nature.
- Lighting: Advanced LED Intelligent Light System for optimal visibility.
Performance and Driving Dynamics
The S 500 4Matic Long is powered by a robust V8 engine, augmented by mild-hybrid technology for a smoother start and a gentle power boost. The ride is supremely comfortable, with the 4Matic system providing excellent all-weather capability.
- Engine: Turbocharged V8 gasoline engine with EQ Boost mild-hybrid technology.
- Horsepower: Typically around 429 hp (may vary by model year).
- Torque: Strong mid-range torque for effortless overtaking.
- 0-60 mph: Around 4.3 seconds (quick for its size and luxury focus).
- Ride Comfort: Renowned for its exceptionally smooth and quiet ride, often considered the benchmark for luxury sedans.
Interior and Refinement
The interior of the S 500 is a sanctuary of opulence. It’s a masterclass in material quality, craftsmanship, and passenger comfort, especially in the long-wheelbase variant.
- Ambiance: A focus on traditional luxury with exquisite wood, leather, and metal finishes.
- Rear Seat Comfort: The long-wheelbase model offers exceptional legroom and often features executive seating options.
- MBUX System: Mercedes-Benz User Experience, featuring an elegant and intuitive infotainment system.
- Sound System: High-fidelity Burmester surround sound systems are standard or optional.
Fueling and Range
As a gasoline vehicle, the S 500 offers the convenience of quick refueling at virtually any gas station. Its range is also substantial, making long-distance travel straightforward.
- Fuel Tank Capacity: Typically around 21.1 gallons.
- Estimated Range: Can achieve over 400 miles on a full tank, depending on driving conditions.
- Refueling: Fast and widely available at any gas station.
Head-to-Head Comparison: Key Features and Specifications
To make the decision even clearer, let’s compare some key aspects of the Mercedes EQS 580 4Matic and the S 500 4Matic Long side-by-side.
| Feature | Mercedes EQS 580 4Matic | Mercedes S 500 4Matic Long |
|---|---|---|
| Powertrain | Dual Electric Motors | 3.0L Inline-6 Turbo with EQ Boost (V8 in some markets/older models) |
| Total System Horsepower | ~516 hp (up to 536 hp with optional package) | ~429 hp |
| Torque | ~630 lb-ft | ~384 lb-ft (V8 equivalent for comparison: ~516 lb-ft) |
| 0-60 mph | ~4.1 seconds | ~4.3 seconds |
| Drivetrain | All-Wheel Drive (4Matic) | All-Wheel Drive (4Matic) |
| Estimated Electric Range (EQS) / Fuel Range (S-Class) | 300+ miles (EPA estimate) | 400+ miles (on a full tank) |
| Charging/Refueling | Electric Charging (AC/DC Fast Charging) | Gasoline Refueling |
| Wheelbase | Standard (EV optimized) | Extended “Long” Wheelbase |
| Infotainment Highlight | Optional MBUX Hyperscreen | Advanced MBUX System, often with rear-seat screens |
| Key Design Philosophy | Electric-first, futuristic, aerodynamic | ICE Pinnacle, traditional luxury, timeless elegance |
Pros and Cons: Helping You Weigh Your Options
Every vehicle has its strengths and potential drawbacks. Considering these can help you align your choice with your priorities.
Mercedes EQS 580 4Matic:
- Pros:
- Zero tailpipe emissions, environmentally conscious.
- Instant torque for incredibly quick acceleration.
- Extremely quiet and refined driving experience.
- Futuristic interior with advanced technology like the Hyperscreen.
- Potential fuel savings with home charging.
- Innovative EV-specific platform allows for spacious interior.
- Cons:
- Charging infrastructure availability and time compared to gasoline.
- Higher initial purchase price than comparable ICE vehicles.
- Battery degradation over time (though typically warranted for many years).
- Range can be affected by extreme temperatures.
Mercedes S 500 4Matic Long:
- Pros:
- Familiar and proven gasoline powertrain performance.
- Quick and easy refueling process.
- Exceptional ride comfort and cabin tranquility.
- Timeless luxury design and craftsmanship.
- Long-wheelbase version offers unparalleled rear-seat space.
- Potentially lower upfront cost compared to the EQS.
- Cons:
- Higher running costs due to fuel and more frequent maintenance (oil changes, etc.).
- Higher carbon footprint compared to an EV.
- Less “instant” acceleration feel compared to electric torque.
- Engine noise, while refined, is present compared to the EQS’s silence.
Is the EQS 580 4Matic the Right Choice for You?
The EQS 580 4Matic is for the driver who is ready to embrace the future of automotive luxury. If you value cutting-edge technology, a silent and smooth driving experience, and the environmental benefits of electric power, the EQS is an exceptional contender.
Consider the EQS if:
- You have reliable access to home or workplace charging.
- You are excited by futuristic technology and design.
- You prioritize a serene and silent driving experience above all else.
- You want to reduce your carbon footprint.
- Your daily driving aligns with the electric range, with occasional longer trips planned with charging stops in mind.
For those looking to understand battery health and charging, the U.S. Department of Energy’s Alternative Fuels Data Center offers great insights into EV battery technology.
Is the S 500 4Matic Long the Right Choice for You?
The S 500 4Matic Long represents the pinnacle of traditional luxury sedans. If you appreciate the refinement, power, and familiar experience of a top-tier gasoline-powered vehicle, and you value the convenience of quick refueling, the S 500 is a superb option.
Consider the S 500 if:
- You frequently take spontaneous long road trips where quick refueling is essential.
- You prefer the traditional driving dynamics and sound of a high-performance gasoline engine.
- You value the long-standing heritage and timeless design of the S-Class.
- The convenience of refueling at any gas station is a top priority.
- You want an ultra-luxurious experience with unparalleled rear-seat comfort in the long-wheelbase version.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: Which car offers a smoother ride?
Both vehicles offer exceptional ride comfort, but the S 500 4Matic Long is often cited for its superlative, almost cloud-like ride quality derived from its sophisticated suspension tuned for maximum isolation. The EQS 580 4Matic is also incredibly smooth and quiet but can feel slightly more connected to the road due to its electric nature.
Q2: Is the EQS 580 4Matic expensive to maintain?
Generally, EVs like the EQS tend to have lower maintenance costs over time than gasoline cars. There are fewer moving parts (no oil changes, fewer brake replacements due to regenerative braking) though specialized battery and electric motor servicing will be required. Mercedes-Benz offers comprehensive warranties on its EV batteries.
Q3: Can the S 500 4Matic Long handle snowy or icy conditions well?
Yes. The 4Matic all-wheel-drive system in the S 500 is designed to provide excellent traction and stability in various weather conditions, including snow and ice. Combined with appropriate winter tires, it’s very capable.
Q4: What is the EQS 580 4Matic’s charging time?
Charging times vary. Using a Level 2 home charger (like those found in many garages), it can take around 11-12 hours for a full charge. With a DC fast charger, you can add up to 180 miles of range in approximately 30 minutes, depending on charging speed and battery temperature.
Q5: Does the S 500 4Matic Long feel as technologically advanced as the EQS?
The S 500 4Matic Long is packed with advanced technology, including the sophisticated MBUX infotainment system, advanced driver assistance features, and premium comfort amenities. However, the EQS 580 4Matic, especially with the optional Hyperscreen, presents a more futuristic and overtly high-tech dashboard experience.
Q6: Which car provides more interior space?
The EQS 580 4Matic, with its dedicated EV platform, offers exceptional interior space, particularly in the rear. However, the S 500 4Matic Long variant, by definition, features an extended wheelbase, providing significantly more luxurious legroom and overall cabin space for rear passengers, often considered the ultimate in chauffeur-driven comfort.
Q7: How do the running costs compare?
Generally, the EQS 580 4Matic will have lower running costs, primarily due to cheaper electricity compared to gasoline prices and reduced maintenance needs. The S 500 4Matic Long will incur costs for fuel, oil changes, and potentially other engine-related maintenance over its lifetime.
Conclusion: Your Personal Journey to Luxury Awaits
Deciding between the Mercedes-Benz EQS 580 4Matic and the S 500 4Matic Long is a delightful dilemma. Both vehicles represent the zenith of automotive engineering and luxury from Mercedes-Benz, offering unparalleled comfort, performance, and refinement.
The EQS 580 4Matic is your gateway to the electrification of luxury, offering a silent, powerful, and technologically advanced driving experience that feels like stepping into the future. It’s ideal for those who embrace innovation and are ready for a sustainable yet exhilarating drive.
Conversely, the S 500 4Matic Long epitomizes the prestige and perfected craftsmanship of the traditional luxury sedan. It delivers its power with renowned grace and provides an environment of serene comfort that has cemented the S-Class as an icon for decades. The long-wheelbase variant ensures that rear-seat passengers experience the utmost in opulence.
Ultimately, the “stunning choice” depends on your personal priorities and vision for your driving future. Both will provide an extraordinary ownership experience, wrapped in the undeniable elegance and quality that only a Mercedes-Benz can offer. Whichever you choose, you’re selecting a masterpiece of automotive design and engineering.